Mass Effect 2 Dilemma – Jack or Tali’Zora‏h

jack vs tali 01 Mass Effect 2 Dilemma   Jack or TaliZora‏h

So Mass Effect 2 has taken over my life for the last 2 weeks as I sail around the universe looking for clues to crush the Collectors. Nearing the end of my journey, I have already accumulated a team of arguably the best that the galaxy has to offer. Sure having a Justicar (the Asari version of a Samurai enforcer), a pure Krogan and Thane Krios (the greatest assassin of the time) onboard is great, but having 5-6 sexy and interested women is making me crazy. For newcomers to the Mass Effect universe, I’ll explain the importance of my last sentence – Mass Effect allows your avatar (Shepard) to develop romances with a crew member and it is one of the best bonuses to playing the game. In the first Mass Effect I went with the Asari scientist Liara T’soni initially, then rethought my justification for doing so and went with my heart Ashley Williams. Since Mass Effect 2 disallowed me the chance to have either of these women aboard my ship for this trip, I thought it necessary to have my man Shepard, move on to greener pastures.

You Must Choose But Choose Wisely
sexy tali Mass Effect 2 Dilemma   Jack or TaliZora‏hThe dilemma for me now is that after many missions, rescue attempts and near death battles with my crew, I am at odds with two women who are more than compatible for Shepard. Being a sucker for punishment, I danced past the obvious choice in the uber sexy Miranda Lawson (if looks were everything she would have zero competition) and opted to woo the sociopathic, murdering, cussing, screaming, tattoo heavy, Subject Zero aka Jack. While most sane individuals would stay far across the other side of the ship to avoid this individual, I made it a point to stay in her face until she liked me. Plus my Shepard is no saint himself, having shot more than a few unarmed individuals for insubordination and various other reasons. I liked Jack because I knew Jack was a product of what was done to her, unwilling to play shrink, I wanted to be a buffer between the normal world and the inner demons which made her lash out. It worked, and after a few missions Jack would welcome Shepard coming down into the engine room to talk with her and after awhile I had him express his feelings for her. Saying it was a mutual feeling in her own little way, Jack asks for some time to think about it and I moved Shepard on to concentrate on the mission.

A few missions later, Shepard’s old machinist buddy Tali’Zorah needed rescuing. Now in the first Mass Effect, Tali was the equivalent of a teenager being made to go through a rite of passage into adulthood. Her main focus was to procure an item of worth to bring back to the Flotilla (her parent’s mothership) and fulfill her Quarian pilgrimage. Shepard was literally her only friend on the ship as I made sure he harbored no Xenophobic prejudices and didn’t hold a grudge against Tali due to her race. Tali is a Quarian, and Quarians are frowned upon in Mass Effect for accidentally unleashing a synthetic menace upon the universe known as the Geth. Since the Geth were responsible for thousands of deaths, people kept the blame of the Quarains strong and their race is treated as second class citizens universally. For Tali, Shepard was different, speaking to her as a friend, making sure her accommodations were comfortable and taking the time to learn more about her race, culture and immediate family.

Upon rescuing Tali, she joins the crew and the old feelings resurface as your conversations continue. This time it seems that Tali has matured into quite a young woman, being stronger, more firm on her wants and desires, and focused. When she is called back to the Flotilla to defend her honor after being accused of a crime, my Shepard stood with her as Captain and defense lawyer. Strangely after this occurrence she and Shepard are talking in Engineering and the topic switches to Quarian mating rituals and how they “do it” (since they are confined to wearing a suit). She let it slip that there has only been one person that she’s felt worthy of risking sickness to share atmospheres with, and as you can guess it’s Commander Shepard.

miranda the hawte Mass Effect 2 Dilemma   Jack or TaliZora‏h

So romance drama has found its way aboard the new Normandy, SIGH! Now that the ice has been broken it becomes a choice of the young Quarian, the scarred ex-con, or to be a good Military Commander and keep my whoring paws off of my crew . Poor me right?

Who would you choose? Or if you have the game and beat it, who did you choose? Are you happy with your decision? I am thinking about doing 2 saves, just because I can but were it one I am leaning towards Tali. What do you think? Does my article make you want to pick up Mass Effect 2?

Other Related Reads:

  • Blitz

    I went with Tali the first time and went with Jack on my second playthrough. I enjoy Tali’s romance plot more than Jack’s which was still pretty good. On the other hand, the romance scene for Jack is alot better.

  • jordan

    i tried all the different love scenes. i have to go with miranda’s scene being the best, followed by jacks, then tali’s being the shortest and dullest. ( dont get to see what tali looks like)

    • http://www.3godkings.com Greg Dragon

      I think most people love the build-up leading to Tali’s romance being that she’s so awkward and innocent… then there’s the whole “she could die from Shepard’s germs” thing which makes it the ultimate in forbidden love. I do agree though on Miranda’s being the best, you see a bit more than anyone elses and the way how she stops you in the elevator like “okay lets do it now” was cool and unexpected.

      If Mass effect 2 were a movie though, I think Jack’s romance would be the preferred in terms of drama and dynamics. Being her commander and the only man who could break through her personal defenses could lead to some really good you know what, but of course Bioware went PG on us this go round. I only wish Kelly had a scene too, kinda sucks that we don’t get to see the date or the “Kelly-gram”.

  • http://www.Herbalizer.ca Ñât

    I went with Jack first, it was good. Went with Tali next time, haven’t done Miranda, but I’ve tried pursuing Kelly, and got as far as the ‘spending the night in my cabin’ thing. When the crew was taken, she died, so I haven’t gotten the chance to see her cutscene and whatnot, but I heard that if you don’t have another relationship and you’ve taken Kelly that far, the end of the game gives you a scene for her. Good luck you guys. Can’t wait for ME3!

  • Raidonlear

    I personally chose to make multiple saves. To be honest I was torn between these two as well, but Tali won out simply due to familiarity. Jack was a quick second. Miranda came last.

    I have this weird view on the old crew members-their loyalty was stronger than the humans (Kaidan and Williams) and chose to follow Shepard even though he/she had seemingly ‘joined’ an pro-human terrorist organisation. Tali makes it clear that she’s not working for Cerberus, she works for Shepard. A distinction that only Jack has made (in her own way upon boarding the normandy and butting heads with Miranda) Plus, the whole cute, sweet, personality tended to win me over. While Jack being Tali’s polar opposite made her a fascinating person to romance, I found that both were well suited for the role as Shepard’s squeeze.

    Regardless, I’m still conflicted on who would be the best partner for Shepard. 

  • Willy the Adult

    It took me awhile to warm up to Zero, but after I did she became my canon LI. I can’t wait until i get ME3 and get to see her again, she’s the definition of cool.

  • reaper

    Miranda is built to be perfect so i picked her. That and she rebuilt you so she knows you inside and out. lol kinda disappointed though since she has low self-esteem and quits cerberus. tsk tsk

Copyright © 3God Kings | Designed by GDyer Web Solutions, LLC. | Admin Login | Images and excerpts used on this site are protected under Article 107 | Fair Use clause of the law. | Contact Us | Privacy Policy